The Metric Thats Fooling Every Credit Union Executive. Credit Union Members are Vanishing Emotionally, Taking Their Engagement & Loyalty To Top Fintechs

The Metric Thats Fooling Every Credit Union Executive. Credit Union Members are Vanishing Emotionally, Taking Their Engagement & Loyalty Elsewhere

By: Ben Malena 💥 Co-Founder AlgoPear

‍

The Silent Crisis Eating Away at Credit Union Growth

Membership growth is the headline credit unions love to share. Quarterly reports boast “record highs” and annual meetings celebrate ever-increasing totals.

But inside those big numbers lives a blind spot large enough to sink long-term growth strategies.

A significant share of those “members” are barely here at all.

The Members Who Vanish Without Leaving

In the industry, they’re known as dormant accounts — members who completed onboarding, maybe made a few transactions, and then simply stopped engaging.

No account closure. No official departure. Just quiet, consistent inactivity.

And the numbers are staggering:

Across the U.S., between 20% and 40% of credit union memberships are functionally inactive on digital channels.

They aren’t gone in the way you can measure — they’re still in your total membership count. But their relationship with your institution is essentially over.

While your systems hold their account, other platforms hold their attention:

• Zelle and Venmo for instant money movement.
• Current and Dave for automated deposits and budgeting.
• Public and Stash for investment opportunities that start with just a few taps.
• Influencer-driven personal finance lessons on TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts.

These aren’t niche platforms anymore. They’re daily rituals for your members. And they’re not just meeting functional needs — they’re delivering education, rewards, and progress tracking in a way that makes traditional digital banking feel… inert.

‍

Why Dormancy Is Not Neutral

It’s tempting to see dormant members as “low risk.” After all, they’re not actively withdrawing funds or closing accounts. But dormancy is not harmless. It’s active value erosion.

Here’s why:

1. Lost Deposits – Dormant members are five times less likely to maintain steady deposit flows or enroll in direct deposit programs. That’s consistent, low-cost funding walking out the door.
2. Stalled Cross-Sells – Personalization only works when members engage. Without interaction, your cross-sell campaigns become noise, and your marketing spend becomes a sunk cost.
3. Investment Gaps – Engagement correlates strongly with activation in wealth-building products. Engaged members are seven times more likely to invest with their primary institution. Dormant ones? Almost never.
4. Silent Churn – Over time, inactivity builds to an irreversible shift. Members start moving daily transactions, then savings, then loans — all without the ceremonial “closure” that would trigger a retention response.

When you add it up, dormancy is costing the industry:

• $19B in missed deposits
• $23B in untapped cross-sell revenue
• $11B in forfeited investment activation
• $17B in loyalty churn

That’s $70 billion annually — and these figures are modeled from observed behavior across top-tier financial institutions.

‍

How It Got This Bad

The roots of the crisis stretch back more than a decade, but the acceleration has been brutal in the last five years.

Fintechs and neobanks didn’t just launch new tools — they launched a new operating system for engagement:

• They adapted to the behavior of members, rather than asking members to adapt to them.
• They designed their apps to look and feel like the digital platforms members use most — social media, streaming services, e-commerce hubs.
• They built engagement loops that react in real time to activity and inactivity alike.

Meanwhile, many credit unions made the critical mistake of equating digital presence with digital relevance.

They built apps, launched online portals, and automated messaging — but left them in static states. For Millennials and Gen Z, these experiences feel less like a service and more like a relic.

The gap is not just technological — it’s cultural.

If your digital platform can’t match the instant clarity and contextual feedback of the other apps on their phone, you’re not just behind — you’re invisible.

‍

The Metric That’s Fooling Everyone

Here’s the dangerous part: most institutions don’t even see it happening because they’re looking at the wrong metrics.

Login counts and app download figures give the illusion of health. But a member logging in to check a balance is not the same as a member setting a financial goal, tracking progress, and taking action toward it.

Passive logins are camouflage for churn. They keep the true scale of dormancy hidden behind vanity numbers.

The platforms that win today are measuring something entirely different:

• Goals achieved
• Financial milestones unlocked
• Personalized nudges delivered — and acted upon
• Questions asked and answered in-app
• Behaviors changed

This is the real currency of digital loyalty. Without it, “digital engagement” is just digital window-shopping.

‍

Selene AI: Turning Dormancy Into Daily Value

That’s where SELENE AI — built by AlgoPear — steps in.

SELENE is not a bolt-on chatbot or another “feature” in your app’s menu. She’s an embedded, intelligent financial wellness assistant that transforms your platform into an always-on engagement engine.

Here’s what makes her different:

• Real-time personalization – Selene meets members exactly where they are, delivering context-aware guidance with the tone and timing of a trusted coach.
• Friction removal – She detects blockers — from stalled account setups to incomplete transactions — and resolves them before frustration turns into abandonment.
• Native investing – Members invest directly within your ecosystem, without third-party detours or brand-diluting referrals.
• Behavior reactivation – Every passive interaction is an opportunity for transformation. Selene turns idle balance checks into coaching moments.
• Brand-first integration – She operates inside your app under your name, amplifying your trust capital while modernizing your experience.

Selene doesn’t just bring members back — she keeps them. Because she builds a daily habit loop that makes your platform part of their financial lifestyle, not just a utility they remember once a month.

‍

The Executive Decision

Dormancy is not a demographic inevitability. It’s the predictable result of outdated engagement design.

The $70 billion gap won’t close itself. But for the institutions that move now, it represents the single largest untapped growth lever in the market.

SELENE AI was purpose-built for this moment — where financial education meets behavior design, and member engagement is the most valuable currency you can own.

The question is no longer “Should we fix dormancy?” It’s “How much more are we willing to lose before we do?”

📅 Schedule your executive demo today and see exactly how SELENE AI reclaims your dormant members before your competitors do.

www.algopear.com | Demo SELENE AI today

‍