“Engagement Is King” — The Single Metric That Predicts a Credit Union’s Future

By: Ben Malena 💥 Co-Founder AlgoPear 

Engagement Isn’t Just a KPI — It’s the Business Model

Let’s be honest: rates, rewards, and even digital banking tools aren’t winning the race anymore. The real game-changer? Engagement.

It’s what every fintech is obsessing over — and what too many credit unions are still treating like a back-burner metric. Engagement is the heartbeat of your entire business model.

The fintechs eating your lunch? They’ve already figured it out. Platforms like Chime, SoFi, Cash App, Coinbase and Robinhood don’t wait for members to need them — they’re built to be part of the member’s daily rhythm.

Meanwhile, Credit Unions are still optimizing for transactions. But today’s member — especially Gen Z and Millennials — isn’t logging in to complete tasks. They’re logging in to build a relationship with their money. And if you don’t provide that relationship? Someone else already is.

Without Engagement, Members Leave — Silently

Here’s the reality check: most of your members won’t announce when they’ve checked out. They’ll still have an account. You’ll still see them in your database. But emotionally? Behaviorally? They’re gone.

They’re not complaining. They’re not upset. They’re just quietly shifting their habits:

• Direct deposits start hitting fintech apps.
• Round-up savings moves to an app with better design.
• Investing? Done through a neobank.
• Financial education? They’re getting it from Instagram and TikTok.

This is the silent churn. And it’s a killer. Because by the time you realize they’re disengaged, it’s too late. The habits are already built elsewhere.

Consider this:

• 44% of Gen Z say they’ve never used a credit union.
• Millennials are 2x more likely to try a fintech app than open a new account at a traditional institution.
• And most alarming? Once they switch, they don’t come back.

This isn’t a brand problem. It’s not even a product problem. It’s an engagement crisis.

‍

Without Engagement, Members Leave — Silently

Here’s the reality check: most of your members won’t announce when they’ve checked out. They’ll still have an account. You’ll still see them in your database. But emotionally? Behaviorally? They’re gone.

They’re not complaining. They’re not upset. They’re just quietly shifting their habits:

• Direct deposits start hitting fintech apps.
• Round-up savings moves to an app with better design.
• Investing? Done through a neobank.
• Financial education? They’re getting it from Instagram and TikTok.

This is the silent churn. And it’s a killer. Because by the time you realize they’re disengaged, it’s too late. The habits are already built elsewhere.

Consider this:

• 44% of Gen Z say they’ve never used a credit union.
• Millennials are 2x more likely to try a fintech app than open a new account at a traditional institution.
• And most alarming? Once they switch, they don’t come back.

This isn’t a brand problem. It’s not even a product problem. It’s an engagement crisis.

‍

Engagement Unlocks Revenue, Loyalty, and Growth

Still treating engagement like it’s just about clicks or likes? Let’s flip that mindset.

Engagement is your most powerful revenue engine — period.

When your members are interacting with your app, consuming personalized insights, completing micro-tasks toward their goals, and receiving smart nudges, you're doing more than driving traffic. You're building behavioral loyalty that leads directly to:

• 34% lift in cross-sell conversions
• 67% increase in deposit retention with daily logins
• 6x higher likelihood of members opening additional products

And it’s not just numbers. It’s psychology. Members who feel seen and supported don’t shop around. They grow with you.

This is how you move from a transactional platform to a transformational partner.

‍

Why Gen Z and Millennials Must Be the Priority

If you think Gen Z and Millennials are just younger versions of your current members, think again. These generations are built different.

They’re used to platforms that feel alive — intuitive, responsive, and personalized. They expect:

• Experiences that adapt to them
• Messaging that feels human, not corporate
• Tools that help them feel in control, not overwhelmed

They grew up with Spotify curating playlists, Netflix predicting their mood, and Google finishing their sentences. They won’t tolerate a banking app that looks and feels like it was built in 2009.

Credit unions have the trust, the mission, and the ethics that these generations respect. But if you don’t match that with UX that feels native to them? They’ll take their money elsewhere — even if they believe in your values.

You don’t just need better marketing. You need better engagement infrastructure.

‍

Engagement Is the Gateway to Financial Wellness

Here’s the secret no one tells you: your members don’t actually want more products. They want progress.

They want to feel like they’re getting ahead. That they’re building something. That their credit union “gets” them.

And guess what creates that feeling?

Engagement.

Because when members are logging in regularly, tracking their savings, learning about investing, and receiving affirming guidance — your app stops being a utility and starts becoming a daily companion.

And that shift drives:

• Higher new account openings (because members refer friends to platforms they use)
• Increased revenue per member (because they engage with tailored offers at the right moment)
• Unshakable loyalty (because you’ve built a relationship, not just a service)

If you want to win the war for attention and wallet share, financial wellness must be delivered through engagement-first design.

‍

SELENE AI: Designed for Engagement, Built for Loyalty

This is where SELENE AI changes the game. She’s not a bolt-on chatbot or another feature buried in a menu. She’s the layer that makes your credit union unforgettable.

Here’s how:

• She speaks like a human. SELENE doesn’t throw jargon at your members. She guides them — with clarity, empathy, and intelligence.
• She listens. Every click, hesitation, and behavior is processed to deliver smarter recommendations, not spammy prompts.
• She sells without selling. Cross-sell moments emerge naturally — when the member is ready, not when it’s convenient for you.
• She gamifies growth. Saving becomes a challenge. Investing becomes a guided experience. Education becomes addictive.
• She speaks Gen Z. From tone to timing, SELENE is designed to feel right to your youngest — and most valuable — future members.

SELENE AI doesn’t just boost engagement. She rewires how members feel about money. And that’s how credit unions win.

Final Word: The Credit Unions That Win Are the Ones That Engage

Let’s be blunt. You can have the best mortgage rate in town. You can sponsor all the community events. But if your digital platform isn’t creating daily, meaningful engagement — you’re invisible.

In 2025, attention is currency. And engagement is how you earn it.

Selene AI gives you the infrastructure to own that engagement — and everything that comes with it:

• Higher lifetime value per member
• Faster cross-sell cycles
• Stronger brand loyalty
• And a platform your members actually enjoy using

Engagement isn’t optional. It’s everything.

Let’s make it the core of your credit union’s growth strategy.

— The AlgoPear Team www.algopear.com | Schedule your executive demo today

‍