Credit Union Engagement Crisis — Why Next Gen (Millennials & GenZ) Engagement is Vanishing and How to Win it Back

By: Ben Malena Co-Founder AlgoPear            

Gen Z Doesn’t Care About Credit Unions — And Millennials Aren’t Far Behind

Not in the way past generations did. Not enough to download the app. Not enough to walk into a branch. And certainly not enough to stay engaged.

That’s not an insult — it’s the data talking.

Engagement from younger generations isn’t just slipping. It’s collapsing. In a world of X, Robinhood, Cash App, TikTok finance influencers, and embedded investing in your favorite brand’s app — credit unions feel stuck in time.

Meanwhile, the fintech world continues to innovate with urgency. Gen Z and Millennials expect digital-first experiences, real-time financial guidance, and personalized platforms that meet them where they already are — on their phones, on social media, and inside apps that understand them.

Here’s the opportunity: the institutions that adapt now can leapfrog an entire generation of digital-first financial behavior and reclaim relevance — not by trying to be fintechs, but by building smarter partnerships with them. And in this edition, we’re going deep into how credit unions can build real engagement, not vanity metrics. This is for the bold — the credit union leaders who refuse to let their relevance expire.

The Engagement Collapse: A Generational Breakdown

‍
Engagement is more than a login. It’s emotional connection. It’s trust. It’s habit. And right now, it’s broken.

According to recent data, only 14–26% of Gen Z currently use credit unions. For many, the brand is invisible, irrelevant, or worse — archaic. Contrast this with fintech adoption: 51% of Millennials say their favorite brands offer better financial tools than banks or credit unions, and 36% of Gen Z prefer non-bank platforms for their financial activity. One study suggests that as little as 4% of Gen Z actively banks with a credit union.

What makes this collapse so alarming is how far the shift has moved. Credit unions once commanded deep loyalty. In the early 2000s, over 60% of Gen X and Boomers reported high satisfaction and engagement with their credit unions, citing trust, community ties, and personalized service. Branch visits were common. Referrals came naturally. Engagement was real. But today, for younger audiences, these differentiators no longer translate.

Credit unions didn’t always have an engagement problem. They were once seen as the human alternative to big banks — community-centered, member-first, and trustworthy. But the digital gap widened quickly. While fintechs built ecosystems for swiping, tracking, investing, and messaging — credit unions were still sending monthly statements and locking insights behind outdated apps.

Why Fintechs and Neobanks Are Winning

‍
Fintechs aren’t lucky. They’re strategic — relentlessly tuned into behavioral psychology, digital habits, and cultural signals. They don’t just think about financial products. They think about attention. They build experiences that trigger curiosity, reward interaction, and cultivate emotional relevance.

Consider how Gen Z and Millennials interact with money:

It’s a daily habit, not a monthly responsibility.

It’s social — they’re sharing trades, savings hacks, and money milestones on public platforms.

It’s visual — dashboards, charts, and swipe-based experiences.

Fintechs win because they understand that financial engagement is psychological. Neobanks and apps like Step, Current, and Greenlight have even gamified the experience for teenagers, training early financial habits long before a credit union account is ever considered.

Even beyond functionality, fintechs inject style, speed, and surprise into the financial journey. A push notification isn’t just a reminder — it’s a conversation starter. A round-up feature isn’t just savings — it’s a micro-moment of gratification. Every element is designed to pull members in — not just keep them active.

The truth is, the new generation doesn’t separate finance from the rest of their digital life. Finance is embedded — in rideshares, in shopping, in gaming. It’s passive when it needs to be, and responsive when it matters. Credit unions have historically existed outside this digital current. That’s no longer sustainable. To thrive, they must move from being a place you bank to becoming a partner in your financial rhythm — daily, relevant, and unobtrusively smart.

‍
The Missing Member Experience: Where Credit Unions Fall Behind

‍
What fintechs have mastered — and credit unions must urgently adopt — is user-centered design. This goes far beyond clean interfaces. It's about meeting Millennial and Gen Z members with seamless onboarding, proactive financial coaching, and frictionless interactions across every channel.

When a Gen Z or Millennial member opens a fintech app, they’re greeted with a journey — not a menu. They’re guided, celebrated, and nudged forward. Compare that to many credit union experiences: outdated apps, clunky forms, generic messages. The financial tools may be there — but the story, the psychology, the emotion, is not.

Credit unions don’t need to reinvent themselves — they need to reconnect. Member engagement in 2025 requires an emotional blueprint: one that responds to behavior in real time, adapts to life moments, and invites users to explore, grow, and belong. This is no longer a “nice to have.” It’s a survival strategy.

If Millennials and Gen Z are the most distracted generations, they are also the most data-literate and curious. They crave clarity, transparency, and control — and they reward platforms that deliver those traits consistently. The experience must feel personalized, frictionless, and even delightful. That means eliminating dead ends, ditching impersonal dashboards, and turning member tools into member journeys.

AlgoPear’s Response: Selene AI and Embedded Wellness that Actually Engages

‍
At AlgoPear , we built Selene AI with a simple premise: financial wellness shouldn’t be boring. Or manual. Or detached from daily life. It should be responsive. It should feel alive. It should engage.

Selene is more than a chatbot. She’s an embedded financial wellness co-pilot that powers real-time engagement across the member journey.

Selene’s Conversational Intelligence turns financial literacy into emotional intelligence. She listens, interprets intent, and responds like a trusted guide — not a robotic assistant. Members don’t have to dig through menus or FAQs. They simply ask questions, and Selene answers — with empathy and clarity.

Selene’s Personalized Journeys are what make her indispensable. Whether a 22-year-old wants to build their first budget or a 35-year-old is planning for their child’s education, Selene tailors every interaction based on behavior, life stage, and financial goals. The more she learns, the smarter she becomes — and the more relevant her coaching.

Embedded Investing through Selene brings financial empowerment to the fingertips of credit union members. No third-party apps. No confusing redirects. Just a seamless path to investing, right inside your app, fully branded to your credit union.

Gamified Growth isn’t just about rewards — it’s about momentum. Selene celebrates milestones, challenges members to level up, and brings dopamine into financial discipline. It’s how we turn “checking your balance” into “checking your progress.”

And with Zero-Lift Launch, credit unions don’t need a data science team or engineering department to deploy this experience. Selene is white-labeled, API-friendly, and built for native integration with minimal lift and maximum value.

Final Word: Credit Unions Deserve to Compete — On Their Own Terms
The fight for attention is real. But you don’t need to chase trends. You need to offer relevance.

Selene AI is the bridge from trust to tech. From legacy to loyalty. From "downloaded and deleted" to "opened daily."

Let’s build that future together.

— The AlgoPear Team *To schedule a strategy session, visit *www.algopear.com

‍